Beyond Headcount: Building a Hybrid Workforce for Year-Round Tax Capacity

Most firms we speak to aren't short of work. They're short of experienced people to prepare and review it.

The numbers behind that are hard to ignore. In the US, new CPA exam candidates fell from 42,626 in 2023 to 28,082 in 2024, a 34% drop. Accounting degrees awarded fell 6.6% in a single year. In the AICPA's 2026 survey of firm issues, hiring experienced staff ranks first for firms with 11 to 30 people. For firms with 101 to 500 people, technology adoption and integration comes first, followed by changes in technology and AI.

The US figures are the starkest, but the pressure is not only American. In HLB's own Survey of Business Leaders 2025, which covered more than 1,200 leaders in over 50 countries, 58% of European leaders said they were concerned about access to talent. Firm leaders across the network will recognize the pattern: fewer people entering the profession, more complexity in the work, and partners pulled back into preparation and review when they should be advising clients.

Depending on a firm's size, these look like different issues. Read together, the survey results describe one root problem: capacity. Smaller firms are trying to solve it by recruiting more people. Larger firms are trying to solve it with better process and systems, getting more capacity from the people they already have. The firms that do best will do both.

Why hiring harder won't close the gap

When capacity runs short, the instinct is to add people, either by hiring locally or by bringing in outside help for busy season. And both leave the firm dependent on individuals: when a key reviewer leaves, the knowledge leaves with them, and the next busy season starts from scratch.

The firms pulling ahead are changing the question. They no longer ask how many more people they need. They ask which work needs which kind of capacity, and how to make sure the outcome doesn't depend on any one person.

The three-layer model

A hybrid workforce isn't onshore versus offshore, or people versus technology. It has three layers, and each piece of work goes to the layer that delivers it best at the right cost.

Layer

What it owns

Typical work

Onshore experts

Judgement, client relationships, sign-off

Advisory, complex technical positions, final review, signing

Global delivery

Ideally process led and outcome based to a defined standard

Return preparation, workpapers, first and second-level review, admin

Technology and automation

Repeatable, rules-based steps, under human supervision

Data intake, reconciliations, checks

 

Onshore experts are the scarcest and most valuable layer. The goal is to give them back the hours they now spend preparing and fixing work, so they can spend them with clients.

Global delivery is where many firms have tried offshoring and been disappointed. It works best when it is process-led and outcome-based. A team that is handed tasks depends on whoever is doing them. A team that runs a documented process to a defined standard, led by a delivery leader who owns the outcome and with review built in at more than one level, can be measured, covered when someone is away, and scaled.

Technology and automation take on the repeatable steps around that work. Used well, they make the process faster and more consistent. They don't replace the judgement of an experienced reviewer.

The value comes from routing work between the layers. A straightforward individual return doesn't need a manager's time, and a complex one shouldn't go to a junior preparer. When each return goes to the most economical level for its complexity, the whole system gets faster without cutting corners on quality.

A worked example: US tax compliance

US tax shows the model under the most pressure. Work piles up around four deadlines: March 15 and September 15 for partnerships and S corporations, and April 15 and October 15 for individuals and C corporations. Firms that run short of reviewers end up extending returns, burning out their teams, and having partners prepare returns themselves.

At SAPRO we build dedicated tax teams in India and South Africa for CPA firms. They cover Forms 1040, 1065, 1120-S, 1120, 1041 and 990, as well as state returns. The biggest lesson from that work is that trust has to be earned before go-live, not after. So every engagement follows the same five steps:

  1. Process and compliance walkthrough. We map the firm's in-scope process, from engagement letters through documents, preparation and review. We agree timing, budget and quality expectations, and confirm compliance requirements, such as Section 7216 consents and data security, before any work starts.
  2. Expert re-performance. Our tax leaders re-perform a sample of the firm's own returns, as many as it takes to learn the process, and compare the results with what was filed. That also highlights process and automation improvements.
  3. Simulation. The team prepares 5 to 10 simulated returns that mirror the firm's real work. They go live only once they have proven they can do it.
  4. Supported go-live. Our tax leaders bring the team onto live returns in the firm's own systems and monitor accuracy, efficiency and communication.
  5. Cross-training and scale. The team is trained across return types and client accounting work, so its capacity stays useful outside busy season instead of sitting idle.

That last step is what turns seasonal help into a year-round operating model. The same team that clears pass-through returns in March can support individual returns and client accounting through the rest of the year.

Once live, every return is prepared with preparer quality checks and then reviewed. Complex individual returns and business returns also get a second-level review. The firm stays the signing preparer throughout.

Where technology fits

We are building automation into our own back office first, with a named person responsible for every automated step and a record of what was done. We are deliberately cautious about claims here. Any firm promised that technology will replace experienced reviewers should be wary. What it can do is take on the repeatable steps around their judgement, so people spend more of their time where it matters.

Even as intelligent technology and agentic AI mature, there will always need to be humans in the loop. They manage the work and, even more importantly, own security and compliance. Here is what we are learning as we build:

  • Set the boundaries first. Decide up front what AI may never do (such as exposing client data to unapproved tools), what needs senior sign-off, and what a system owner can approve.
  • Keep a human accountable for every step. An AI agent that can act inside firm systems needs a named person who supervises it and approves its output.
  • Test what it shouldn't do, not just what it should. Checking that an agent stays inside its permissions matters as much as checking its answers.
  • Keep a record. Every run, check and approval is logged, so the firm can show what was done and stand behind it.
  • Where is your bottleneck: preparation, review or admin?
  • How many returns did you extend last season, and why?
  • Is your process documented well enough for someone new to follow it?
  • Which steps are repeatable enough to automate?
  • Who in your firm would own the outcome?

Trust is part of the design

A hybrid model only works if clients and regulators can trust it. For US tax work, that means written taxpayer consent under Section 7216 before return information is shared outside the US, and a written data security plan. Rules differ by country, but the principle is the same everywhere: controls have to be designed in from the start. Our delivery runs under an ISO 27001:2022-certified information security management system, with multi-factor authentication, encrypted and locked-down devices, and data loss prevention. For AI, we have chosen the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF) to shape our protocols, so that every deployment leads with security and keeps compliance front of mind.

Where to start

Before choosing a provider or a tool, it helps to answer a few questions honestly:

  • Where is your bottleneck: preparation, review or admin?
  • How many returns did you extend last season, and why?
  • Is your process documented well enough for someone new to follow it?
  • Which steps are repeatable enough to automate?
  • Who in your firm would own the outcome?

The answers usually show that the problem isn't a shortage of people. It's a shortage of capacity designed around the work.

Talk to us

We run a 45-minute discovery workshop to map where your busy season pinches, find where capacity is lost, and outline what a hybrid model could look like for your firm. If you have US tax work, we can also show you how we would re-perform your own returns before anything goes live. Book a discovery workshop

 Dedicated SAPRO teams prepare and review US returns for CPA firms, led by a named Delivery Leader.